All the castaways have been making video diaries to document their personal feelings about the trip and each other. After waking one morning, they find that the tapes have been stolen, and they all worry that their secrets will be exposed.
When Nathan and Daley fight over who should be the leader of their group, Nathan tries to light a signal fire, while Daley looks for a suitable campsite. Meanwhile, the pilot and three of the kids decide to search the island.