Romeo discovers that Gary's swim coach is related to a famous record producer, so he and Louis hesitantly try out for the swim team in an attempt to hustle a connection for the band. The only problem is that Romeo can't swim! Louis' tryout efforts gain him a spot on the team, and the coach offers Romeo an irresistible deal – if he takes lessons from her, she will present their band's demo to her uncle, the record producer. Will a record deal help him overcome his fear? Meanwhile, Mrs. Rogers goes on a spending spree, using Percy's money to buy useless household gadgets, and Jodi must utilize her recently obtained knowledge of Psychology 101 to figure out why.
Romeo and Louis' attempt to become the school's number one prankster backfires when they accidentally destroy a precious school trophy. Myra uses her evidence-collecting abilities to find the vandals, and when she discovers it was Romeo, she blackmails him into being her boyfriend. Meanwhile, Mrs. Rogers attemps to prove herself able to cornrow Gary's hair, despite her race.